How to Tell a Great Tall Tale

As someone just starting her liveaboard journey, my sailing skills are… optimistically competent, but as a documentary producer, I do know the in's and out's of a great tall tale. 

I’m always on the lookout for a sun damaged sailor with stories. 

They’re the people who remind us that storytelling isn’t always about accuracy. It’s about creating moments of wonder, humor, and shared laughter.

The tall tale has long been celebrated in maritime culture. These exaggerated stories like the fish that got away, but not just any fish, a monster ... this blends fact and fiction to entertain and connect us.

But capturing an audience takes more than that. Without style and finesse, a tall tale is just lies. 

It’s a fine line.

The best stories resonate with universal truths about the human condition, while also showcasing unique perspectives.

Let’s deep dive into this art form so you can tell your own tall tales.

1. Humans Are Story-Driven Creatures

Storytelling taps into how our brains naturally make sense of the world. We seek meaning and resolution, and stories help us process experiences, emotions, and challenges.

Frame your sailing tales in a way that offers meaning. Why did this event matter? How did it change you?

2. Every Story Needs a Protagonist with a Problem

All great stories are about a character who wants something and encounters obstacles in getting it. The tension between desire and difficulty is what keeps people engaged.

Structure your story with a clear goal, challenge, and resolution. Even a small mishap can become epic in the right hands.

• Desire: We wanted a really good night sleep after the challenging, cold, wet day of sailing.
• Obstacle: But suddenly we were woken up by the assumption that we’d grounded. Also, possibly sustaining a mild concussion in the chaos.
• Resolution: The anchor line issue was a lot less serious than we thought and we laughed at the experience.

3. Transformation Makes Stories Great

The best tales reveal a transformation - how the protagonist grew, changed, or learned something. It’s this arc of growth that makes stories feel universal.

4. Show, Don’t Tell

The heart of storytelling lies in showing, not telling. Use vivid sensory details to bring the audience into your world. Let them feel the moment.

Instead of “The storm was bad,” try:

• The wind howled 
• We were battered by waves
• The boat would drop down hard with a BOOM
• Salt stung my already dehydrated lips 

5. Embrace Conflict and Imperfection

Perfection is boring. Conflict, mistakes, and flaws are what make stories relatable and engaging. Don’t be afraid to share your blunders. They’ll make your audience laugh with you, not at you… hopefully.

Let’s continue the maritime tradition of telling great stories

Sailing is full of moments that range from awe-inspiring to cringy. This is part of what makes life on the water so amazing. 

The beauty of a great tall tale is that it doesn’t have to be perfect; it just has to be yours and have a kind of energy behind it.

Who knows?

The next time you’re at anchor with a group of salty sailors, your story might just be the one that lasts after you're gone.

‍